top of page

Sixteen Years of Ultra Poison: 50k Winners over the years

11 minutes ago
5 min read

Sixteen times since 2009 we have sent a field out for four loops of the hills at Horseshoe Valley, and sixteen times somebody has come back first. We went through every result from every year to see who they were. Ten different women and thirteen different men have won the 50k, and a handful of them didn't stop at just one win.


The woman who beat everybody


Start with Laurie McGrath, because the record book does. She won the first three editions, 2009, 2010 and 2011, and nobody of either sex has won three in a row since.



Her 2010 run of 4:59:38 is still the fastest 50k a woman has run the Pick Your Poison course. In sixteen years, no other woman has finished under five hours. Lisa Van Wolde came within a minute and a half in 2013.


In 2011. Laurie crossed the line in 5:11:50, and the first man, Ken Arnott, arrived four minutes and thirteen seconds later. It is the only time a woman has won Pick Your Poison outright. It was not a fluke of a thin field, either: April Boultbee was third overall that day and her twin sister Melanie fourth. Three of the first four finishers were women.



The women who came back


Laurie started something. Five women have won the 50k more than once, against two men.


April Boultbee won in 2012 and again in 2017, five years apart, the second time by three minutes and thirty-six seconds, the tightest women's finish we have had. Chantal Demers won in 2014 and returned to win in 2019. Krista Allen took 2022 and 2023 back to back; in 2022 she was third overall and more than forty-three minutes clear of the next woman. Paula Morley, second to Krista in 2023, then won the next two herself.


Melanie Boultbee, fourth overall in that 2011 race, got her own win in 2018, which puts twin sisters on the winners list three times between them. And Lisa Van Wolde may be the most consistent of the lot: one win in 2013, second the year before and the year after, and back on the women's podium in 2017.


Sarah Cushnie, 2026 female winner in her first Pick Your Poison
Sarah Cushnie, 2026 female winner in her first Pick Your Poison


The men


Jeremy Walsh is the men's answer to Laurie, with three wins of his own: 2013, 2016 and 2023. Seven years separate the last two, and his 4:15:02 in 2023 was faster than his winning time in 2016.


Corey Smith owns both ends of the men's record. He won the very first race in 2009 in 5:16:28, on an afternoon that reached 27 degrees, and it remains the slowest winning time we have. Three years later, on a morning that started below freezing, he ran 4:01:07. That is the course record, and nobody has come within seven minutes of it since. The closest anyone has ever been is Alistair Munro, who ran 4:04:54 that same day and finished second.



Ken Arnott deserves a line of his own. Second in 2009, second in 2010, and first man home in 2011, the year Laurie was already there waiting.


Clifford McCarten, 2026 overall winner after a 2nd place in 2025, just 1 minute 56 seconds behind Ed Heung
Clifford McCarten, 2026 overall winner after a 2nd place in 2025, just 1 minute 56 seconds behind Ed Heung

Close ones and runaways


The closest finish in race history came in 2025, when Ed Heung held off Clifford McCarten by one minute and fifty-six seconds after four and a half hours of running. Clifford came back in 2026, on the wettest day we have ever had, and won.


The biggest winning margin belongs, of course, to Laurie: fifty-one minutes in 2009. The biggest among the men is Corey Smith's twenty-four minutes the same day.


Winners do not hang around


Add up every finish by all twenty-three winners and you get fifty. That is barely two each. Nine of them have a single finish to their name, and it was a win.


Laurie McGrath and Jeremy Walsh have each finished this race exactly three times. Three finishes, three wins. Krista Allen and Chantal Demers are two for two.


The winner with the most finishes is Lisa Van Wolde, with five, and four of them ended on the women's podium. She shares that record with Karen Batsford, who was third among the women in 2018 and 2019 and second in 2022 and 2024. Four podiums, and the top step is still waiting for her.


Winning times, fastest to slowest


The time at the top of each table is the course record.


Women

Rank

Time

Winner

Year

1

4:59:38

Laurie McGrath

2010

2

5:00:58

Lisa Van Wolde

2013

3

5:02:44

April Boultbee

2012

4

5:08:26

April Boultbee

2017

5

5:09:23

Krista Allen

2023

6

5:11:50

Laurie McGrath

2011

7

5:12:12

Paula Morley

2025

8

5:14:11

Chantal Demers

2014

9

5:15:26

Angie Darbyson

2015

10

5:16:15

Krista Allen

2022

11

5:25:38

Chantal Demers

2019

12

5:36:18

Melanie Boultbee

2018

13

5:37:18

Paula Morley

2024

14

5:48:06

Sarah Cushnie

2026

15

5:48:48

Heather Borsellino

2016

16

6:07:17

Laurie McGrath

2009


Men

Rank

Time

Winner

Year

1

4:01:07

Corey Smith

2012

2

4:08:15

Jack Sikkema

2017

3

4:09:25

Jeremy Walsh

2013

4

4:15:02

Jeremy Walsh

2023

5

4:20:10

Adam Takacs

2014

6

4:22:11

Rob Vanderwerf

2015

7

4:25:07

Alistair Munro

2010

8

4:30:08

Ed Heung

2025

9

4:33:53

Jordan Collison

2018

10

4:37:47

Richard Pady

2019

11

4:44:22

Jeremy Walsh

2016

12

4:45:08

Giancarlo Otani

2024

13

4:57:09

Clifford McCarten

2026

14

4:59:22

Danny Tresise

2022

15

5:16:03

Ken Arnott

2011

16

5:16:28

Corey Smith

2009

The race was not held in 2020 or 2021.



Wins, finishes and podiums

Winner

Wins

Finishes

Podiums

Best time

Laurie McGrath

3

3

3

4:59:38

Jeremy Walsh

3

3

3

4:09:25

Corey Smith

2

3

2

4:01:07

April Boultbee

2

3

3

5:02:44

Paula Morley

2

3

3

5:12:12

Krista Allen

2

2

2

5:09:23

Chantal Demers

2

2

2

5:14:11

Lisa Van Wolde

1

5

4

5:00:58

Ken Arnott

1

4

3

4:43:09

Danny Tresise

1

4

2

4:42:36

Melanie Boultbee

1

3

3

5:20:34

Alistair Munro

1

2

2

4:04:54

Clifford McCarten

1

2

2

4:32:04

Rob Vanderwerf

1

2

1

4:22:10


Race Directors On The Podium

Our own Race Director, Trish Mintz, has found her way to the podium as well. Racing as Trish Benoit, she was second among the women in 2016 and second again in 2019. She finished the 50k four years in a row from 2016 to 2019.


One win from one finish

These runners showed up once, took their win, and never came back.


Adam Takacs (2014), Angie Darbyson (2015), Heather Borsellino (2016), Jack Sikkema (2017), Jordan Collison (2018), Richard Pady (2019) and Ed Heung (2025)

Comments


© 2026 by Pick Your Poison Trail Race

Pick Your Poison (🅿️☠️🅿️) is an ultra trail race held annually in April in the Copeland Forest, Barrie, Ontario, Canada in support of mental health awareness and charities.

bottom of page